Interesting discussion and reflection from the FCA 1 year on from the implemenation of the consumer duty for open products and as the same for closed products goes live.
For similar summaries and updates subscribe to the RO-AR.com newsletter.
Key Points
- The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has successfully implemented the Consumer Duty for open products, and now for closed products as well, aiming to enhance consumer protection and industry standards.
- The Consumer Duty is designed as an outcomes-based regulation to foster healthy competition and innovation within the financial services industry.
- Firms have embraced the Consumer Duty, using it to shift culture and improve outcomes through more transparent practices and the elimination of charges such as early withdrawal fees.
- Significant improvements in consumer outcomes have been noted, including faster response to base rate changes and better treatment of cash balances by investment platforms.
- The duty encourages firms to adopt a customer-centric approach, revising employee bonus structures to align with customer satisfaction.
- The integration of the Consumer Duty in both open and closed financial products marks a significant advancement in regulatory practices.
- Technological advancements, like digital wallets, are shaping the future of consumer banking needs, prompting the FCA to adapt its regulatory approach to support innovation without compromising consumer protection.
- The FCA’s new secondary objective to support the UK’s international competitiveness highlights a strategic direction towards sustainable economic growth through effective competition.
- Collaboration with the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) ensures consistent application and interpretation of the Consumer Duty, enhancing its effectiveness.
- Firms are encouraged to participate in a feedback process to simplify the FCA’s rulebook, ensuring regulations remain adaptive and responsive to industry changes.
- The FCA is focusing on fostering an environment where profits are not made at the expense of consumer fairness, emphasizing that good consumer outcomes can coexist with healthy profits.
- The duty’s flexibility allows smaller firms to adopt practices that fit their specific business models and customer needs.
Innovative Techniques and New Ideas
- The FCA’s approach to regulating through an outcomes-based framework allows firms the flexibility to innovate while ensuring consumer protection.
- Implementation of digital hubs and AI sandboxes facilitates safe and rapid product development, helping firms to navigate regulatory landscapes efficiently.
- The introduction of a “tell us once” approach to customer service improves efficiency and reduces repetitive customer interactions across different points of service.
Key Statistics
- Base rate increases led to an average 0.5 percentage point increase in rates for easy access deposits between July 2023 and February 2024.
- Consumers are projected to receive an additional £4 billion annually in interest payments due to proactive rate adjustments by firms.
- Changes in GAP insurance commissions are expected to save customers around £70 million.
- Approximately £10 million annually will be returned to customers’ pockets due to improved practices around interest on cash balances.
Key Discussion Points
- The impact of the Consumer Duty on firm behaviour and consumer protection.
- Challenges and successes in implementing the duty across both open and closed products.
- The role of technology and digital finance in shaping future regulatory focuses.
- The balance between consumer protection and the promotion of industry innovation and growth.
- The importance of cultural shifts within firms towards consumer-centric models.
- The ongoing collaboration with the Financial Ombudsman Service to ensure consistent application of the Consumer Duty.
- Feedback mechanisms and the importance of industry engagement in regulatory processes.
- How smaller firms can effectively apply the Consumer Duty within their specific operational frameworks.
- The need for continuous improvement and adaptation in regulatory practices to match industry and consumer evolution.
- The role of data and metrics in understanding customer needs and improving service delivery.
- The potential need for revisions in the FCA’s rulebook to reduce complexity and enhance clarity for firms.
- The strategic use of complaints and oversight data to monitor and guide firm behaviours under the new regulatory regime.
Industry Comment and Reaction
Key points of note
- Consumer Complaint Trends: There has not yet been a significant increase in complaints related to consumer outcomes or understanding, with most complaints still focused on areas like credit cards, overdrafts, and motor finance.
- Digital Transformation: Financial services are undergoing digital transformations primarily to save costs for firms, which may not always align with consumer benefits.
- Consumer Duty Awareness: There is ongoing concern about whether new consumer duties are entering public consciousness and impacting daily financial decisions.
- Interest Rate Disparities: There is growing consumer awareness and dissatisfaction regarding the disparity between interest rates for savings and overdrafts when benchmark rates rise.
- Regulatory Consultations: Recent consultations are focusing on digital wallets and their role in preventing fraud, alongside broader regulatory impacts on consumer choice and financial products.
- Operational Resilience: There is heightened emphasis on operational resilience in response to recent threats, like those highlighted by CrowdStrike incidents, showing a need for continuous improvement in security practices.
- Fintech Standards: Fintechs are being pushed to meet high regulatory standards, comparable to major banks, to maintain reliability and trust in the financial system.
- Evidencing and Data Integrity: There is a strong focus on the need for firms to demonstrate compliance and improvements through solid data and evidence, not just claims of adherence.
- Sector-Specific Regulations: Different sectors, including debt recovery and insurance, face varied regulatory expectations, particularly around practices like fair value and customer service.
- Regulatory Updates and Deadlines: The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has updated its guidelines on consumer duty, emphasising new sections on vulnerability and board reports, with clear compliance deadlines.
- Cultural Change and Training: Firms are expected to invest in training and competence programs to align staff actions with both internal policies and FCA expectations.
- Technology and Policy Development: There is an ongoing need for policies around emerging technologies like AI, ensuring they are integrated responsibly into consumer financial services.
RO-AR insider newsletter
Receive notifications of new RO-AR content notifications: Also subscribe here - unsubscribe anytime
