INSIGHTS ¦ Buy Now Pay Later: Understanding and Addressing the Risks to Consumers – Summary Report



The report provides a comprehensive analysis of the usage patterns and demographic profiles of Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) users in the UK, highlighting the broader financial and societal impacts of these services. It examines the potential harms associated with BNPL products, especially under the constraints of the COVID-19 pandemic, and discusses necessary regulatory measures to protect consumers.

Key Points

  1. BNPL products are used by approximately 33% of the UK population, debunking the stereotype that they are primarily used by younger, female consumers.
  2. Users often come from diverse backgrounds, though certain groups—such as those with dependent children, higher incomes, or recent life events—are more likely to use BNPL.
  3. The research challenges the portrayal of BNPL users in media and marketing, showing a broader demographic engagement.
  4. BNPL usage has surged during the pandemic, with 42% of past users engaging with BNPL services within the last year.
  5. The increase in BNPL usage is linked to online shopping trends and the economic impact of the pandemic, suggesting that these services offer a critical financial lifeline for some.
  6. BNPL users are characterized by their attitudes towards risk, time, and trust in financial services, which may expose them to greater financial harm.
  7. There is a significant correlation between experiencing life events or financial distress and increased BNPL usage.
  8. Regulatory gaps exist due to the rapid growth and evolution of BNPL services, outpacing current financial oversight frameworks.
  9. Proposed regulations focus on enhancing transparency and introducing frictions in the borrowing process to ensure informed consumer decisions.
  10. The survey reveals that BNPL users are not a homogenous group, necessitating tailored regulatory approaches to address varied consumer experiences and risks.
  11. The profile of a typical BNPL user is more complex and financially established than commonly portrayed, often juggling multiple financial responsibilities and stressors.
  12. Future research and policies should consider the nuanced realities of BNPL users to develop effective consumer protections without stifling financial innovation.
See also  [INSIGHTS]: Rising Cost of Living - Joint Regulatory Dear CEO letter

Key Statistics

  • 33% of UK adults have used BNPL services.
  • 42% of BNPL users have utilized these services in the last year, coinciding with the pandemic.
  • Households with dependent children are 71% more likely to use BNPL.
  • An income increase from below £10,000 to over £50,000 raises BNPL usage likelihood by 64%.
  • Experiencing a life event increases the odds of using BNPL by about 35%.
  • Users under financial stress (missed payments, etc.) are more likely to use BNPL, with odds increasing by 38%.

Key Take Aways

  • BNPL is not just for the young or financially naive; it serves a wide demographic with varied needs and circumstances.
  • Regulatory frameworks need to catch up with the rapid adoption and evolution of BNPL services to prevent potential financial harms.
  • Enhanced transparency and responsible lending practices are crucial to protect consumers while maintaining the benefits of BNPL.
  • Providers should standardize disclosures and terms to improve consumer understanding and decision-making.
  • Policymakers should consider the financial and psychological impacts of BNPL, particularly in the wake of economic stresses like the pandemic.
  • The diversity of BNPL users implies that one-size-fits-all regulations will not be sufficient; nuanced approaches are required.
  • The relationship between BNPL use and life events suggests that these services are often used as emergency financial aid, highlighting the need for consumer-friendly repayment options.
  • Attitudinal data on BNPL users indicates a potential vulnerability to impulsive buying and financial misjudgments, necessitating educational initiatives and better consumer support.
  • The disparity in missed payments and debt levels across different BNPL providers suggests that smaller or niche providers may require more stringent regulatory oversight.
  • Consumer protection should prioritize transparency about the risks and costs associated with BNPL to prevent over-indebtedness.
  • Future policy interventions should balance consumer protection with the innovative benefits provided by BNPL services.
  • Ongoing research and dialogue with stakeholders are essential to ensure that BNPL regulations are effective, fair, and adaptive to market developments.

RO-AR insider newsletter

Receive notifications of new RO-AR content notifications: Also subscribe here - unsubscribe anytime