[INSIGHTS]: FS2/23 – Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning

ABOUT: The Bank of England and Financial Conduct Authority reveal insights and feedback on the adoption of AI in financial services.

LINK: Read the full publication


The Bank of England, in collaboration with the Financial Conduct Authority, has released a comprehensive feedback statement, FS2/23, following their initial discussion paper on Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Machine Learning (ML). This document, a culmination of extensive industry engagement, reflects a wide array of perspectives, emphasizing the rapid evolution of AI capabilities and the necessity for dynamic regulatory guidance. The feedback underscores the importance of ongoing industry engagement, the complexities of the regulatory landscape, and the potential risks and benefits associated with AI, particularly concerning consumer outcomes and third-party model dependencies.

Key Points and Ideas

  • The industry suggests avoiding a rigid regulatory definition of AI due to its rapid evolution.
  • Stakeholders advocate for ‘live’ regulatory guidance, updated periodically, to keep pace with technological advancements.
  • Continuation of initiatives like the AI Public Private Forum (AIPPF) is encouraged for sustained public-private engagement.
  • There’s a call for greater coordination among domestic and international regulators to address the fragmented regulatory landscape.
  • Emphasis on consumer outcomes, highlighting the need for regulation to focus on fairness and ethical considerations.
  • Increasing reliance on third-party models and data raises concerns, necessitating more regulatory guidance.
  • The complexity within AI systems requires a holistic approach across various business units for risk mitigation.
  • Existing firm governance structures are deemed sufficient to manage AI-related risks, with no need for additional frameworks.
  • The feedback statement refrains from policy proposals, focusing instead on summarizing responses and identifying themes.
See also  [INSIGHTS]: Consumer Vulnerability: Evidence from the Monthly COVID-19 Financial Well-being Survey

Key Statistics

  • The discussion paper (DP5/22) received 54 responses from diverse stakeholders.
  • Industry bodies constituted almost a quarter of the respondents, with banks representing an additional fifth.
  • No significant divergence in opinions was noted between sectors, indicating a consensus on key issues.

Key Takeaways

  • Regulatory strategies need to be as dynamic and adaptable as the AI technologies they govern.
  • A principles-based or risk-based approach, rather than a fixed definition of AI, is recommended for effective regulation.
  • Ongoing dialogue and collaboration between regulators and the industry are crucial for informed policy-making.
  • The regulatory framework must prioritize consumer protection, especially in terms of fairness and ethical implications of AI.
  • Firms are leaning heavily on third-party models, highlighting the importance of understanding and managing associated risks.
  • The industry believes in the efficacy of existing governance structures in mitigating AI-related risks, suggesting enhancements only in specific areas.
  • The feedback collected is instrumental for the authorities as they continue to assess the implications of AI and ML in financial services.
  • The authorities are expected to consider all responses in depth as they forge ahead with their AI-related programs and regulatory strategies.
  • The comprehensive nature of the feedback underscores the industry’s commitment to responsible AI adoption.
  • The document serves as a foundational reference, informing future discussions and policy directions in the realm of AI in financial services.
  • The emphasis on a harmonized regulatory approach reflects the industry’s desire for clarity and consistency in AI governance.
  • The collective response underscores the need for a balanced approach, safeguarding consumer interests while fostering innovation.

RO-AR insider newsletter

Receive notifications of new RO-AR content notifications: Also subscribe here - unsubscribe anytime